Star Cluster · Deep guide
Messier 73
Also called: M73 · NGC 6994
Four stars that only look like a cluster: a chance line-up, not a family.
What is it?
Messier 73 is a small group of four stars in Aquarius, just east of the globular cluster M72. Messier recorded it in 1780 as a cluster of four stars with some haze; John Herschel later saw no haze and doubted it was a real cluster. Astronomers debated the question in the early 2000s. Gaia measurements settled it: the four stars lie at very different distances, from about 1,030 to 2,290 light-years. So M73 is an asterism, a chance alignment on the sky, not a true star cluster.
The deep dive
Researched for the Atlas from Wikipedia — Messier 73 (2,815 characters read) · updated Nov 15, 2026
01 How Charles Messier First Saw It
Charles Messier logged M73 in 1780, describing what he saw as a cluster of four stars accompanied by some nebulosity — a faint, misty glow surrounding them. That reported nebulosity turned out to be significant, because it was the very detail that gave the grouping any claim to being something physically real rather than just a pretty coincidence. When John Herschel examined the same patch of sky much later, he could find no trace of nebulosity whatsoever. Herschel was openly skeptical that M73 deserved to be called a cluster at all, yet he was thorough enough to include it in his General Catalogue of clusters, nebulae, and galaxies anyway. John Dreyer then carried it forward into his New General Catalogue, giving it the designation NGC 6994. So M73 entered the canonical lists of deep-sky objects largely on the momentum of historical inclusion, even as doubts about its true nature were already on the record.
02 Four Stars or a True Family?
The core question about M73 is deceptively simple: are its four bright stars actually neighbors in space, or do they just happen to line up along our line of sight? For most of astronomy's modern history that question went unanswered. In the early 2000s it became a genuine scientific controversy, with different research teams publishing contradictory conclusions within the same year. The debate matters because sparsely populated open clusters — groups of stars born together from the same gas cloud — can look almost identical to random asterisms when only a handful of members survive. Getting the classification right requires more than just a pretty picture; it demands precise distances, colors, luminosities, and measurements of how each star is actually moving through space.
03 The 2000 Debate That Split Astronomers Deeper
The year 2000 produced three separate studies of M73, and they did not agree. L. P. Bassino, S. Waldhausen, and R. E. Martinez analyzed the colors and luminosities of the stars in and around M73 and found that the four central bright stars, along with some neighboring stars, followed the color-luminosity relationship characteristic of open clusters as displayed on a Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. Their conclusion was that M73 was an old open cluster roughly 9 arcminutes wide. In the same year, G. Carraro performed a similar analysis and reached the opposite conclusion: the stars did not follow any coherent color-luminosity relation, making M73 an asterism. A third team, led by E. Bica, added yet another layer by arguing that the chance alignment of the four bright central stars plus one additional nearby star was statistically highly unlikely — lending support to the cluster interpretation. Three papers, two contradictory verdicts, and no clear resolution — until two years later.
04 How Spectra Settled the Argument in 2002 Deeper
The definitive answer came in 2002 when M. Odenkirchen and C. Soubiran analyzed high-resolution spectra of the six brightest stars within 6 arcminutes of M73's central point. Spectra carry two critical pieces of information that photometry alone cannot provide cleanly: the precise distance to each star derived from its intrinsic brightness versus apparent brightness, and the star's radial velocity — how fast it is moving toward or away from us. Odenkirchen and Soubiran demonstrated that the six stars lay at very different distances from Earth and were moving in different directions from one another. Stars born together in a cluster share a common origin and therefore travel together through the galaxy; these stars clearly did not. The conclusion was unambiguous: M73 is an asterism, a chance alignment with no physical connection among its members.
05 What Gaia Revealed About the Distances
The Gaia space mission later provided extraordinarily precise distances to each of M73's four bright stars individually, using the third early data release known as Gaia EDR3. The results make the random nature of the grouping vivid in plain numbers. The closest of the four stars sits about 1,030 light-years from the Sun, with an uncertainty of just 9 light-years. The second star lies at 1,249 light-years — and that star is itself a binary, meaning it is actually two stars orbiting each other. The third star is 2,170 light-years away, and the fourth reaches out to 2,290 light-years. The nearest and farthest members are separated by roughly 1,260 light-years along our line of sight — a gap comparable to the distance from the Sun to the nearest star multiplied by hundreds — yet they appear to sit side by side in the sky.
06 One of the Four Is Actually Two Stars
Gaia EDR3 data revealed that the second star in M73's quartet, sitting at a distance of 1,249 light-years with an uncertainty of 10 light-years, is not a single star at all but a binary system — two stars gravitationally bound to each other and orbiting their common center of mass. This detail underscores how even the simplest-looking objects in the sky can conceal complexity. To the naked eye or a small telescope M73 appears to be four points of light; a more careful look reveals that one of those points is itself a double. The article does not specify the properties of the individual binary components, but the fact that Gaia's precise astrometry could detect this pairing from thousands of light-years away is a testament to just how powerful modern space-based measurements have become.
07 Why Asterisms Still Deserve Scientific Study Deeper
Once M73 was classified as an asterism rather than a cluster, one might expect astronomers to move on. But the scientific community has argued that studying objects like M73 carefully is still valuable, precisely because the boundary between a true sparse cluster and a chance alignment of unrelated stars is genuinely difficult to locate. A systematic survey of many such ambiguous groupings would reveal how frequently open clusters are disrupted and scattered by gravitational forces operating within the Milky Way. Stars in open clusters are not bound together as tightly as those in globular clusters, so the tidal forces from passing giant molecular clouds, spiral arms, and the galactic disk can gradually pull them apart. By cataloguing which apparent clusters turn out to be asterisms and which retain physical coherence, astronomers can build a more complete picture of the forces shaping the galaxy's stellar population over time.
08 M73's Neighborhood: Next Door to M72
M73 lies several arcminutes east of M72, a genuine globular cluster also located in the constellation Aquarius. The proximity of these two Messier objects on the sky is a coincidence of projection rather than any physical relationship — M72 is a true gravitationally bound sphere of hundreds of thousands of old stars, while M73 is four unrelated stars that happen to share the same small patch of sky from our vantage point. The pairing does make them a convenient target for observers scanning the region, since finding one often leads naturally to the other. Aquarius sits in a part of the sky sometimes called the "Sea" or "Water" region of the celestial sphere, an area historically populated with water-themed constellations in many cultures.
09 How to Find and Observe M73
M73 is a faint and unspectacular target by most standards — four faint stars gathered in a tiny patch of sky in Aquarius, with an apparent magnitude of 9.0. That magnitude means it lies just beyond the reach of the naked eye under even perfect dark skies, but a small telescope or a good pair of binoculars will reveal it without difficulty. Because M73 is so compact and sparse, it offers little of the visual drama of a rich open cluster or a globular. Its historical interest is what makes it worth seeking out: this is one of the few Messier objects that turned out not to be what Messier thought it was, and tracking down an asterism that fooled astronomers for over two centuries carries its own quiet reward. Finding M72 first and then nudging the field of view a few arcminutes to the east is the most practical approach.
10 M73's Place in Messier's Catalog
Charles Messier compiled his famous catalog in the late eighteenth century not as a guide to beautiful objects but as a practical tool to avoid confusion: he was a comet hunter, and fuzzy or clustered objects in the sky could be mistaken for new comets at first glance. M73 sits near the end of Messier's list, logged in 1780. The fact that it consists of only four stars, with no genuine nebulosity confirmed by later observers, makes it one of the most debated entries in the catalog. M73 is sometimes cited alongside M40 — a double star — as an example of Messier objects that turned out to be neither clusters nor nebulae in any astrophysically meaningful sense. Their presence in the catalog is a reminder that even careful, dedicated observers work within the limits of the instruments and knowledge available to them.
11 Open Questions That M73 Raises Deeper
Even with M73's nature settled as an asterism, the case raises questions that remain active in the field. How do astronomers reliably distinguish the last survivors of a dispersed open cluster — which might number only a handful of stars in a small area — from a random alignment? A dying cluster's stars would still be moving in roughly the same direction because they once shared a common velocity, even if they have drifted apart in space. An asterism's stars, by contrast, will have unrelated velocities. The 2002 Odenkirchen and Soubiran study used exactly this velocity test to settle M73's status. Applying such tests systematically across many candidate sparse clusters, now made far more practical by Gaia's all-sky precision measurements, is an ongoing research program. M73 itself became a kind of methodological case study for how to approach the problem.